*mandatory* Course reflections
Please comment on these questions
- What have you learned in this course that surprised you?
- Would you take another course in philosophy if money/time weren't major barriers?
- Do you have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics?
- Have you developed an appreciation for the relevance of metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical questions in our daily lives?
- Have you improved in your skills of analysis and critique, as well as in written and oral communication due to this course?
The thing that I have learned most in this course is the sheer amount of confrontation associated with each problem and each particular case, and I would find enjoyment in taking another course. In attending this course I have acquired a deepened knowledge behind the philosophy of biomedical ethics and strengthened my understanding of the subcategories metaphysical, epistemological, and daily ethical questions that we are faced with in today's world. This course has improved my analytical skills as well as my communication skills by having to draw conclusions as well as finding similarities between two oppositions of thought and having to communicate it verbally and on paper.
ReplyDeleteI've learned that people have more diverse viewpoints that I could have imagined. I have also learned that some people were ignorant of what I thought was well known about certain things, and that I myself was ignorant about things that most other people knew about. It was a great mutual educational experience. I would take another philosophy course if it was structured similar to this and dealt with societal issues. I do not really like philosophy classes about learning the ancient or medieval theories, although I understand that they are important. I have definitely gained a better appreciation for different ethical problems and the many different ways one can address them. I would say my ability to logically argue and critique others' arguments has improved in a significant way.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe one thing that I have learned in this course is the different ways doctors have to make decisions. I had no idea that all these ethical procedures took place. From my experiences in the doctors, I felt that if the patient agreed to something most of the time the doctor followed suit. The face that they do take in consideration the moral and ethical values makes me feel more confident in the people that take care of me in hospitals. I hope that each doctor from the past has used these techniques when dealing with me.
ReplyDeleteI have developed a new appreciation for my understanding of the philosophical dimensions. One in particular is Ross' principles. The idea of these principles are what I try to model myself off of each day. This course has also helped me to develop my communication on this subject. I had no idea who Kant was before this course began. Now I can get into a good argument of why he would say a certain thing about an ethical situation, while feeling confident in what I have to say. If I could take another course similar I think I would, but only if Professor Cate teaches it. I believe another teacher would not be as entertaining with such a difficult topic as this one.
In this course I have learned a lot about our current healthcare system and the discrepancies that exist within it. Especially during the forum I learned how the smallest factors can contribute to large changes such as budgeting and providing care for all. Also, I have learned more about the issue that end of life care has become and how the government and many individuals are pouring so much money into futile treatments. Yes, I would definitely take another course in philosophy (like Josh sais-if it was with Dr. Cate!). I feel like from learning them at the beginning semester and applying the philosophical dimensions to so many cases and scenarios has helped me grasp what they really mean. The basic ideals such as Utilitarianism, Kant, Care ethics, etc are easier to understand when put into real life scenarios. This class has definitely helped me look out for current events and when I do hear a news story related to healthcare around the world I am able to look at it through the different lenses of ethics, metaphysics and epistemology. Lastly, as I have already stated, I do believe that by looking at different real life cases and arguing with classmates and Dr.Cate I have a better understanding of how to form an opinion and more importantly gather information to support my opinion. Through Dr.Cate asking questions and forming an opposition as well as looking at a case from the perspective of the opposite opinion I was able to better understand my own.
ReplyDeleteI this course I learned a great deal more about how we as people deal with questions of health care, and more interestingly, dying. I would absolutely take another philosophy course if I could, provided it was a sufficiently interesting subject. I feel like I have a much better understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics, especially when it comes to care for the elderly and dying. I think my appreciation for the metaphysical, epistemological, and ethic questions I encounter in my daily life has remained about the same, if only because my college experience had radically ramped up my consideration of them. I do think my communication skills, both oral and written, have improved in terms of discussing philosophical topics, but perhaps not so much overall.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Keith. I felt like most people just disagreed with health care because of who made it rather than what it actually did. the fact that it is this complex and requires this much thought made me think more about it.
Delete1. The biggest thing that surprised me is how we treat the elderly. It’s disturbing what people get away with in our society today, in regard to treating the elderly.
ReplyDelete2. I would not take another philosophy course. Even though it is extremely interesting, it is not my cup of tea.
3. I think I have a pretty good understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics.
4. I don’t know if I would say I have developed an appreciation. I would say that I have developed a basic understanding of metaphysical, epistemological and ethical questions in our daily lives.
5. My critique skills have definitely improved and my analysis skills have slightly improved, due to this course. My written and oral skills/communication have slightly improved as well.
The biggest thing that surprised me was how different everyone's viewpoints were in our small class. I thought since we were all about the same age and lived in the same area our viewpoints would be more similar. I would love to take another philosophy class if it was structured similarly. I didn't care for my last philosophy class because it was more lecture and didn't help me find where I stood on particular problems. This class definitely helped me gain a better understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics, especially when looking at the care of the elderly. I gained a better understanding of end of life care and how damaging it is to our health care system when trying to prolong someone's life who has no chance of making it. I have also developed an appreciation for the relevance of metaphysical, epistemological and ethical questions in our daily lives. I believe my skills of analysis and critique have improved through this class, especially my writing skills.
ReplyDeleteThe ways in which our country can reduce healthcare costs and still get the care that we need surprised me. The forum was very helpful in understanding what options our country can adopt to reduce costs of healthcare. I would take another philosophy course as long as it deals with death and dying or the health field. Philosophy classes help me dig down deep and help me understand my own beliefs about certain situations. The cases in the back of the book are a good example of situations that test my moral and ethical beliefs, but it the end it has only made them stronger. I have learned that all healthcare issues need to be discussed properly such as a forum to assure that the ethical and moral codes are met. The theories learned throughout this semester such as Utilitarianism and Kant can help decide the right decision and action to take. I really like applying ethical questions to the end of life circumstances because it interests me. I volunteer in hospice and I often think about what is morally and ethically right, whether the patient is getting the right kind of care. I have gotten better at my writing skills and being able to analyze and think philosophical during this semester. My favorite paper was Pellegrino’s essay about The Virtuous Physician and the Ethics of Medicine.
ReplyDeleteWhat surprised me greatly was how much you can support an argument by looking at the other side and being forced to argue FOR that side. Because, when you do, you find flaws for that side. What comes to mind is the exercise we did for the cosmetic surgery argument towards the beginning of the semester.
ReplyDeleteYes and no. Sometime I feel like, with subjects covered in this class and in philosophy in general, the instructor's personal agenda can be pushed upon the students. Not saying that happened in his class! But, it's a risk that can be apparent.
Yes. After participating in class, I have certainly learned the dimensions(and complexities l) that can e found within bioethics.
Yes. Because we aren't usually forced to think outside the box like this, very often. Usually, we would just go day to day wth our own bells and not much abrasion (for the most part), because we stick to our guns, keep quiet and our heads down (generally; there certainly are more vocal people out there than the average person). This class certainly opens your mind about philosophy,
thinking and examining your own (and opposing) beliefs.
Yes, definitely. I am a Schwartz, and the Schwartz side of my family is a very argumentative and debate-loving family.
I'll admit, that I certainly pulled back on my family's throttle in this class, because when we argue and debate, we get heated. Also, i honestly don't have much incentive to argue and disagree (passionately) with my classmates and football teammates, so I held my tongue a lot of the time. But, to answer the question, it certainly has augmented the argumentative side of me to use at my next family gathering..
What have you learned in this course that surprised you?
ReplyDelete- Something in this class that I have learned and was surprising was how much we learned when we took a step back and had to argue for our opposite viewpoint. This helped us gain a better understanding of what we are arguing for.
Would you take another course in philosophy if money/time weren't major barriers?
- I would take another course if time and money wasn't an issue because philosophy classes make you think outside of the box and discuss why you believe what you do and how it can relate to others views.
Do you have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics?
- I have a better understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics than before this class, but then again my understanding wasn't that great before.
Have you developed an appreciation for the relevance of metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical questions in our daily lives?
- I have developed an appreciation for the metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical questions for our daily lives. Sometimes I find myself asking questions I normally wouldn't about what I do in my daily life and how they might affect my future.
Have you improved in your skills of analysis and critique, as well as in written and oral communication due to this course?
- I have improved my skill of analysis and critique as well as written and oral communication. I tend to sit back and listen to other people's argument before responding so that I can get a better understanding of their side.
What have you learned in this course that surprised you?
ReplyDeleteI have learned a lot about the ethics of health care. I like arguing my point and seeing what others argue about so we can possibly come to an agreement. I learned different perspectives and how to take in consideration someone else's opinion so it could better my understanding. I learned perspectives of biomedical ethics from Kant to Utilitarian Etc.
Would you take another course in philosophy if money/time weren't major barriers?
I would take an philosophy course, I really appreciate taking classes like this. It makes you think and it gets you involved.
Do you have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics?
I do, I have definitely grown to appreciate the philosophical dimensions considering i came in to this class knowing nothing but the importance of health care.
Have you developed an appreciation for the relevance of metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical questions in our daily lives?
I have developed an appreciation for the relevance of all of these. I constantly put into question what i am doing now in my daily life that will affect myself or others in the future.
Have you improved in your skills of analysis and critique, as well as in written and oral communication due to this course?
Yes. This class was the first class that I was able to express myself freely and to think outside the box. I like having conversation and hearing new ideas everyday. My favorite part was presenting to the class and taking control of the conversation, it made me realize how much I like teaching to other people and engaging in others about something I am knowledgeable about.
What have you learned in this course that surprised you?
ReplyDeleteFocusing on more recent information, I found it shocking the differences between the national averages and our local stats. It points out the local drug epidemic we are waging war against. It was something that I was never really exposed to or forced to think about.
Would you take another course in philosophy if money/time weren't major barriers?
Absolutely. I intend to take another class. Though it be a requirement, I am sure I will enjoy it.
Do you have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics?
Sure. I am now able to understand and appreciate all medical decisions and the various philosophical approaches that could be used in application to a question in order to arrive at several different solutions. I am now able to cognitively discuss several viewpoints on the same question.
Have you developed an appreciation for the relevance of metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical questions in our daily lives?
Yes. I now appreciate all medical professionals that face these questions daily. I also appreciate the thought that goes into those decisions. However though I am still fuzzy on what I would actually do in half of the situations, I appreciate them being brought to my attention, giving me plenty time.
Have you improved in your skills of analysis and critique, as well as in written and oral communication due to this course?
Perhaps. Trying to make a coherent argument supported by evidence and theory has been my goal. I think that most of the time I didn’t sound completely incompetent.
What have you learned in this course that has surprised you?
ReplyDelete- The healthcare elsewhere was very interesting and surprising. It is crazy to see how people live all around the world. You can also see all of the struggles they face, especially the 3rd world countries, and not feel so bad about America's situation and be grateful for what we have.
Would you take another course in philosophy?
- I think this was one of my favorite courses at Thomas More thus far. It was very interesting as well as intellectually challenging. So, yes I would take something like this again.
Do you have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics?
- I definitely have more of a sense of that now than I did. I have definitely advanced in my philosophic approach compared to my freshman year when I took philosophy of science.
Have you developed an appreciation for metaphysics, epistemology, and ethics in our daily lives?
- I think that taking philosophy courses make you question a lot of things that you normally would not see. It kind of opens your eyes to things that are interesting and new. We as humans love the unknown, so questioning the world and the things in it are so important for our daily lives. So, yes I have developed an appreciation for this from both of my philosophy classes.
Have you improved in you skills of analysis and critique as well as in written and oral communication?
- I believe that I have. In this class we had to do a presentation as well as read and speak in discussions. Other peoples views can change your opinions and also change the way you see things so hearing what others say is eye opening a lot of the time. This eye opening helps to critique someone's views because you see it in another light.
1) What have you learned in this course that surprised you?
ReplyDeleteA lot of things surprised me during this course. It amazes me that theres a difference between other peoples beliefs. During the debates, it's crazy how easily angered some people get when trying to make people believe them (I'm guilty as well). Also, learning different BioMedical standpoints have helped me view working at a hospital differently and has allowed me to become a more passionate in care.
2) Would you take another course in philosophy if money/time weren't major barriers?
I would and in fact, I'm taking Death and Dying in the fall.
3) Do you have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics?
I do! It's easier for me to understand doctors' decisions and the background behind medicine.
4) Have you developed an appreciation for the relevance of metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical questions in our daily lives?
This course has helped me reevaluate my personal opinions and broaden my horizons when it comes to certain aspects. I also see why it's important for different doctors with different specialities. Also, it's crazy how healthcare is different throughout the world. Yet the US is paying more and not having as great of an outcome?
5) Have you improved in your skills of analysis and critique, as well as in written and oral communication due to this course?
I have improved my communication and written skills as well as putting thought to paper through critical analysis. In studying different cases with different opinions, it helps you see a different side of the matter. This class also keeps you on your toes as far as making sure theres a clear understanding of all material covered.
1.) The one thing that has surprised me most about this course would have to be the people within the class. My classmates feel very strongly about certain things in the class and it was interesting to see how controversial it could get at times in class.
ReplyDelete2.) I would easily take another course in philosophy, I have enjoyed coming to class and would recommend it to anyone who needs to take a philosophy course.
3.) I would like to think I do, throughout this course it has showed me the many things doctors, nurses, etc. have to do in order to get their jobs/tasks completed.
4.) This course has helped me see from different perspectives in bio ethics. I never knew about all the possible situations that people in healthcare have to deal with and it has made me appreciate the little things that all the people do in health care.
5.) I have improved with my written and oral skills due to the fact that you have to be able to look at different sides of arguments and not just your own. This course has helped me evaluate situations and use my critical thinking skills more than any other course I have taken at the college. The material was easy to learn due to how interesting it was. It has furthered my thinking not only in this course but throughout schooling, it has made me think and look at all possibilities.
1. I've learn a lot about what happens behind the medical scene and how to think ethically and morally about certain situations that I would have brushed off before and not have cared to give much thought about.
ReplyDelete2.I think I would take another course in philosophy, depending on the topic. I think that learning about people is more interesting, and during this course I learned a lot about others but more about myself.
3. I do think I have a better understanding of biomedical ethics. I understand more about what the doctors, patients, and everyone in between have to go through and what they have to think about, in an ethical way.
4. I have definitely developed multiple perspectives when in comes to the appreciation for ethics in my life. I take into consideration more than I use to because I now know how to think more rationally.
5.I believe i've truly improved on my analysis of situations more. I also feel more comfortable talking to my peers about situations that are tougher to understand, but I also now know how to speak about those situations and use correct terminology to state my points.
ReplyDeleteThe thing that surprised me the most in this course is how many different issues are involved in ethics in the medical field and how many different schools of thought they can be analyzed from. I found that on many issues I would have an immediate impulse as to what the right thing was, but through this class I began to analyze cases by looking at them from several viewpoints which in the end gave me a much more developed and well thought out stance on the issues.
I am taking Death and Dying in the fall because I found that aspect of this class to be particularly interesting and I heard the class is taught by Dr. Cate who is too good of a teacher for me to not want to be in more of her classes. I also think a course on business ethics might be cool since I will probably own my own vet practice in the future (or at least that is the plan) and having a background in business ethics might be beneficial.
I do have a philosophical view of the study of biomedical ethics because I now know there are several ways to think about cases and several schools of philosophy that bioethical issues can be analyzed from.
I have a much greater appreciation for these type of questions in my life because sometimes a religious or legal analysis of situations is not enough and more answers can be provided if I develop an ethical argument for my beliefs as well.
I never have enjoyed arguing or felt that I was very good at it but this class helped me to take stances on issues and then back them up with sound reasoning and I now feel much more comfortable standing up for and supporting my beliefs on issues.
1. One thing I learned in this course that surprised me was how awful US healthcare is compared to the rest of the first world. As a whole, we need significant healthcare reform and better health management. Like Dr. Cate said in class, we do not have a health care system as much as we have a sick care system.
ReplyDelete2. Yes, I would take another philosophy class. I would probably be more interested in another ethics class, as I did like looking at the different cases from the different points of view of the ethical theories.
3. Yes, I do think that I have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of biomedical ethics. By looking at the same situation through different lenses, I can see how people can make different decisions based on what they consider to be ethical.
4. There are not too many of the cases we discussed that apply to my daily life, as I am not a healthcare professional, but I would say I am more aware of when I use a Utilitarian argument for doing something.
5. I do think that this class has helped to improve my oral and written skills, in addition to my critical thinking skills. I found myself thinking about the arguments that could be made against each theory and how I could use that theory to overcome the argument.
This is my third time writing this reflection because it keeps deleting. I really loved this course and would definitely take another philosophy class as long as you are leading it. I have learned about bio medical ethics and how hard it is for doctors and nurses to make decisions especially when it does not agree with their morals. I have learned a lot about critical thinking and getting in depth when discussing these topics. My oral and written skills have definitely improved because of this. I would not say these topics applied to my daily life but I do know that these stories are real and it has made more more aware of these things.
ReplyDeleteWhat have you learned in this course that surprised you?
ReplyDeleteWhat surprised me the most was learning about how there are so many different kinds of healthcare systems implemented across the world.
•Would you take another course in philosophy if money/time weren't major barriers?
Yes, I would take another philosophy course. Its interesting and fun to take a course that actually debates different issues that are happening in world.
•Do you have an understanding of the philosophical dimensions of the study of biomedical ethics?
I feel I do have an understanding of the different dimensions by taking this course.
•Have you developed an appreciation for the relevance of metaphysical, epistemological, and ethical questions in our daily lives?
I feel that I have developed an appreciation for it. There are so many different viewpoints that we need to take into account when dealing with different choices in our daily lives.
•Have you improved in your skills of analysis and critique, as well as in written and oral communication due to this course?
I feel that it has improved my skills of analysis and critique by forcing us to argue the other side of what we believe in.
I've learned so much about how deep the ethical issues really are in healthcare and the reasons for why they are so important to debate.
ReplyDeleteI loved this class and found every discussion very intriguing and will definitely be taking another philosophy class.
I have learned to ponder more often about the ethical issues in daily life.
My skills in every aspect have greatly improved especially with critical thinking and public speaking.